The Full Metal Alchemist Collab is one of the most highly anticipated events to come to North America as it features the game changing Edward . Unfortunately, the rest of the Collab is mediocre as a whole since most of the other cards have niche or situational value at best.
This leads to an unfortunate conundrum as one of the best cards in the game can be acquired here but you also run the large risk of rolling numerous fodder cards instead. Comparing Full Metal Alchemist to events such as Heroine, Dragon Bound & Dragon Caller, and Monster Hunter, the lack of value at the bottom (and even the top excluding Edward) may make it challenging for many players to spend their Magic Stones. Granted Full Metal Alchemist is only priced at 5 Magic Stones per roll, it may just result in you being disappointed twice as often.
As such, the decision of whether to roll or not to roll will still come down to individual preference and how much you value the cards outside of general usability.
—video coming soon—
Full Metal Alchemist REM
|6 Star base|
|5 Star base|
Full Metal Alchemist Collab Rankings – March 2, 2018
Order within each tier is random and not reflective of ranking
Regardless of card’s ranking, you should always keep it if it is your very first time acquiring them
6 Star base
Edward Elric – S/SS
Edward is the most valuable card in the entire Full Metal Alchemist Collab and will be the top prize players will be aiming for. This is because he is considered one of the best leaders in the entire game which may come as a surprise if you just look at the multiplier shown.
Edward is able to lead a health conditional team that can achieve 144x ATK / 57.75% damage reduction. However, you must be above 50% HP to trigger your damage reduction/some damage and the other component for ATK comes from forming 6 or more combos. Thus, Edward is a combo-based leader who is deceptively tanky along being wonderfully easy to activate as you only need to achieve 6 combos.
Edward is an amazing leader due to his ease of activation, no team building restriction, and high survivability. However, his main crutch will be the HP-clause that forces players to remain above 50% HP to enjoy his full multiplier and damage reduction component.
One interesting aspect to the HP-clause is that if you are able to heal back up above 50% while comboing, you will regain your damage reduction component to survive the next attack (you will not regain the damage boost) so this can lead to an interesting stalling strategy. This can naturally become problematic if facing a spawn that has a 1 turn timer but his active skill provides a full heal.
However, the HP-clause is not a large enough barrier for Edward teams as you are able to deliver massive amounts of damage on a consistent basis provided you can hit 7 combos every turn (which should almost always be doable).
144x ATK is not very impressive overall, but when you start factoring in multiple 7 Combo awakenings, your damage can skyrocket. For example, Edward comes with two 7 Combos which means he will enjoy a personal 4x damage which essentially propels his effective multiplier to 576x for himself whereas an Ideal would boast 1,152x damage. As such, building a team with numerous 7 Combo subs will lead to explosive damage while still retaining the damage reduction component.
Due to Edward’s non-restrictive leader skill, he has flexible team building options but should still try to keep the following points in mind:
- Have full colour coverage
- Utilize subs with 7 Combo awakenings
- Prioritize high HP cards
- FUA as required
Full colour coverage is important to sustaining Edward’s health through his base active skill and his Skill Charge awakening. By being able to successfully match all 5 colours, Edward will enjoy 1 turn of personal haste to charge his active up faster. This will naturally apply to your friend Edward as well to help ensure you can heal at a moment’s notice.
As stated above, Edward’s base multiplier is “low” but is ea sily compensated by heavy usage of 7 Combo subs. By having all cards on your team with at least one, your effective multiplier quickly ramps up to explosive levels.
In addition, by prioritizing high HP cards, you can help stay above 50% more easily. While a 1,000 HP difference between subs may not feel like a big deal, it can actually mean the difference between full multiplier and using Edward’s active. Furthermore, each point of HP you have will go even further when you factor in the damage reduction component. Thus, using a card like Amatsu as opposed to other FUA options is advantageous.
Speaking of FUA, this awakening has become almost a mandatory inclusion on end game teams. Furthermore, many FUA cards do come with offensive awakenings which makes it easier to include them on any given roster.
Active skill and awakenings
Edward’s active skill comes with a lengthy 20 turn cooldown but is offset by his Skill Charge Awakening. Skill Charge enables the owning card to gain 1 turn of personal haste when you match all 5 elements. Thus, his 20 turn cooldown can be reduced down to 10 if you have a board with 5 elements each turn. This is important as it allows you to use the healing component to push yourself above 50%. While your damage reduction can be regained by healing mid combo, the damaging component only triggers if you were above 50% before moving orbs.
Due to the nature of Skill Charge causing the base card to have a longer cooldown, it diminishes Edward’s potential to be used as an inherit or sub on various teams if the rainbow clause is not met.
In terms of potency, the active does help you remove hazards while also providing more light orbs for additional damage.
Overall, Edward is one of the strongest monsters to be released and if you could pick 1 Collab card to own, Edward may be the top pick from many players.
Alphonse Elric – A
Alphonse Elric is another 6-star base card from the Full Metal Alchemist Collab and while he has reasonable potential, he will be overshadowed (like the rest of the Collab) by Edward.
Alphonse owns a Dark Kali style active skill that comes with a 50% damage reduction component. Overall, this is a reasonable active skill as it fulfills both a board changer that produces hearts and a damage reduction component. Furthermore, Alphonse’s awakenings make him a desirable, bind immune card on a variety of teams. Many FUA come with some offensive awakenings, but few are bind immune which can lead to potentially safer clears as one key card is able to dodge various binds. Furthermore, Alphonse comes with 2 Skill Boosts which is somewhat rare on FUA cards.
As a leader, Alphonse has modest potential as he can also achieve 144x ATK, but must match 4/5 colours along with no HP/damage reduction component. Furthermore, his RCV aspect is tied to his 4/5 colour match which makes stalling problematic overall.
With all that being said, Alphonse’s value dramatically increases if you were fortunate enough to pull Edward as his Light/Wood typing, FUA, 7 Combo, and full bind immunity enable him to act as a stellar sub.
Roy Mustang comes with a powerful double orb changer that does not remove hearts while also enhancing fire orbs on an 11 turn cooldown. This may feel appealing, but you also have to remember that mono-colour leaders have been slowly dying out due to combo-based teams enjoying far more consistency overall. Thus, it may be hard to justify Roy’s place on most meta teams as he could potentially make too many fire orbs.
With that being said, Glavenus Hunter may find merit in his orb changing and enhancing aspect as it can provide more damage along with being able to combo with a Red Sonia board changer.
As a leader, Roy forms a 144x ATK / 9x RCV team when matching 2 fire combos with one being 5o1e. Thus, you require 8 fire orbs to deal respectable damage which is problematic on a regular 6×5 board while also having your RCV component linked to matching two sets of fire. As a result, he will be difficult to play efficiently while also being vulnerable to binds.
King Bradley – C
King Bradley is an interesting card as he comes with a truly unique active skill as he is able to deal 150,000 True Damage to an enemy 5 times (will switch to a different target if first one dies).
This may seem strange at first as you are only dealing 750,000 total damage which falls short compared to other button options such as Grimjow but the True Damage and staggered nature leads to interesting advantages.
True Damage means the damage is not altered by defense so you are able to deal 750,000 damage every single time. However, by having each strike only deal 150,000 damage five times enables King Bradley to sneak under various absorption shields. For example, Sopdet will absorb any hit exceeding 200,000 and by hitting for 150,000 damage prevents the absorption from occurring and can make for an easier time when facing her. This can naturally be applied to any lower threshold absorption spawn.
Sadly, with the relative abundance of Fujin style actives, the true need for this type of damage is diminished. As such, it may be hard to justify using King Bradley as it is not a guaranteed kill. Furthermore, it will take 3 Bradley actives to kill a single Sopdet. Another interesting aspect is you can kill Parvati and dodge her Jammer making resolve but this is bordering on luxury.
Thus, one may find some merit in some Ranking Dungeons (if we ever get those again) as it can enable you to button through low health spawns but is slower compared to Grimjow due to longer animation.
As a leader, King Bradley does form a 7×6 board but is easily eclipsed by Diablos due to Bradley’s orb hungry nature.
5 star base
Winry Rockbell – C
Winry Rockbell has a truly interesting active skill as it provides 30% max HP heal every turn for 4 turns along with 30% damage reduction for 4 turns. Together, she does provide a unique twist on sustain, but neither option is truly amazing along with the heal occurring after you match (like autoheal awakenings). This means that HP-sensitive teams will not receive their full multiplier if they have their health pushed above afterwards but will apply for the damage reduction component Edward enjoys.
Either way, it is something to be considered in niche situations but unfortunately it is a situaltional active skill overall and hard to justify using Winry over other shielding options.
Riza Hawkeye – C
Riza Hawkeye has a middling kit as they are able to remove 3 turns of awoken binds along with dealing 40 True Damage to a single enemy three times.
The awoken bind clearing component is situationally helpful, but you probably have better options overall (such as Odin Dragon ) so their main niche will be for dealing with Dark Metatron Tamadra or fully evolved Zeal.
Both of these spawns void damage above a tiny threshold and Hawkeye is able to slip underneath bothand remove them in one go. While both spawns are able to be dealt with, the speed in which Hawkeye can clear them can open up doors for certain farming practices. Furthermore, if the initial target dies, Riza will target someone new so you can remove up to three high defense/low HP spawns.
Maes Hughes – C
Maes Hughes comes with an orb unlock and +1 combo count for 1 turn on a 6 turn cooldown. This is sadly a low value active for both the small perks and mediocre cooldown. While each component can have some merit, neither are particularly powerful and you will often have better options available.
Perhaps their 3 SBR may have some value, but again you probably have stronger options available. With that being said, Maes has some potential on Liu Bei teams for both the unlock, wood rows , and SBR coverage
Overall, Maes Hughes may feel like a Hughes waste of 5 Magic Stones.
Alex Louis Armstrong – D
Alex Louis Armstrong may workout and have more hair on his face than head, but neither can compensate for his niche kit. His active skill enables you to convert all hazards into Light orbs along with 3 turns of 50% skyfall chance for enhanced orbs.
Sadly, both these components are middling and hard to use well as you must actually have Jammer or Poison orbs present for the orb changer and having a +50% increased chance for enhanced orbs only plays well if you can capitalize on Heart orbs for the healing boost.
Scar – C
Scar is best viewed as an inheritable Anji as he can reduce all enemies’ defense to 0 along with a 50x ATK of all your team’s Dark ATK. This enables you to instantly kill a high defense floor and then have the subsequent floor defense broken as well. However, this niche button farming ability is not really needed as simply acquiring various skill up fodder for True Damage or the Dark Male Hunter can often produce the same or better end results. Furthermore, Scar comes with a hefty 24 turn cooldown which makes it challenging to actually charge him up in time, let alone when used as an inherit.
Ling Yao – B
Ling Yao is the final card in the Full Metal Alchemist Collab and is yet another niche card to roll. He is able to provide 100% damage reduction for 1 turn along with 2x ATK for Wood and Dark cards on an 18 turn cooldown. If they had excluded the lackluster damage enhance component, the cooldown could have been a few turns shorter and thus more easily inheritable.
What keeps Ling Yao valuable is they can reduce damage from any spawn and he does not mess up your current board like Raphael . However, the actual need to run this kind of shield is quite niche unless you are playing HP-sensitive teams or need to survive a truly monstrous attack.
The Full Metal Alchemist Collab is a painfully top heavy event with only one real prize: Edward . However, the sheer power and potency of Edward will be enough to entice many players to heavily roll as they will gain access to what is arguably the best leader in the game.
Let me know what you think about the Full Metal Alchemist Collab and how much you plan on rolling.
|Mantastic Social Media|
If you enjoy my content, please consider turning off AdBlocker for this website =)
32 thoughts on “Full Metal Alchemist Collab Review and Analysis – March 2018”
Prepare to pay a huge price to chase for only ONE card, and I agree that in others collab like Dragon Bound even if you do not get the top price there are still a lot of useful cards, I would like to say that is “An equivalent exchange” of your wallet ^_^
Thanks for the review! And here I was, all excited… that’s a lot of mediocrity in that thar machine…
Its to make it harder to get Edward =P
Wouldn’t it be great if the free rank 50 roll excluded all the lower rarities? But to obtain (Edward), something of equal value must be lost…
Keep dreaming =P
I’m a huge FMA fan, so completely biased. I’m going to roll but I’m not sure how much, especially because I seem to be cursed with rolls as of late. Even so, a few of the cards seems useful enough situationally, at least moreso than the trash I’ve been rolling.
However, I rolled Diablos the first MH collab and Ideal as well, so thinking I’ll get Edward too is pushing it a bit.
Well hopefully Edward blesses you with his presence! And I concede that many players are rolling for the love of the collab so hopefully it works out for you =)
Ed blessed me with his presence, so did everyone else. TBH I sold every duplicate I got except Ling, Alphonse and Roy and I’m torn with the decision because I won’t be able to get them max skilled.
Is the wording on this card wrong on padx, or did it get changed?
Effect: All attribute cards ATK x3 when HP is greater than 50%. ATK x2 at 4 combos. ATK x1 for each additional combo, up to ATK x4 at 6 combos.
Original: 3x ATK & reduces damage when HP is 50% or more; ATK increases with 4+ combos, up to 4x
Both of those still result in the same 144x ATK and damage reduction. Just the effect is more detailed for his damage scaling
LikeLiked by 1 person
I feel like the pull rates while not great aren’t crazy. %2.5 per 6* is a far cry from the %0.65 of many 6 stars in the regular rem. Granted, you have a potential to get many %0.65 in the rem vs many many of the same pull in a collab. I guess that’s how people get pulled in.
So far, i have gotten Bradley and Alphonse. I am assuming it is Alphonse’s leader skill that stops him from being S; because in today’s meta he is a very solid sub. 7C, unbindable, FUA, Time extends. The only drawbacks are his low RCV and that his skill doesnt guarantee 5 heals for FUA.
For Alphonse he somewhat hinges on having Edward as that is probably his best team overall to use as a sub as it makes use of his colour n sub colour etc. However, Amatsu n cotton are usually better options on other teams
True. But I have 0 Cotton and 0 Amatsu.
What other FUA options do you have?
Well I’m not really starved for FUA options. I have several Dragonbounds, Norns, Kami, Paimon, Y’shtola and now Alphonse.
I’m just saying that even though Cotton and Amatsu are better options, these 6* exclusives might not have been attained by others. And it doesn’t negate that Alphonse is a great card.
I rolled a bit over a pack and got Edward, he was my only diamond. With 10% chance of a diamond, the RNG didn’t seem to be on my side, but at least I got the guy.
I would take Edward over several copies of the other diamonds =P
Got Bradley on my First Pull.
I rolled a few times at midnight and got the wrong elric brother, but for some reason the fact that the origin of the collab is so dear to me made me not feel bad about buying stones, i rolled Ed on the first roll of the pack i bought, guess buying hundreds of dollars of merch was worth!
Oh wow congrats on getting Ed right away! Who do you plan to use on his team?
Two Ling Yaos out of two. Might inherit on tardis
I would just inherit the largest stat booster possible on Tardis or something with extra awakenings since you are only using his base active skill
2 scars 1 edward
That is pretty Fantastic!
I quit PAD last year after my tablet died and took my two accounts with it (I couldn’t be bothered to deal with GH support). This week my PAD itch needed scratching so I decided to start a new account and after watching your video on Ed, re-rolled till I got him as a starter.
Been pretty satisfied since! He’s a powerhouse and even with a shitty team (Ed/Awoken Athena/Tyrannos/Riza/Hera) along with Ed helpers I’ve been clearing all content I want pretty easily. Only rank 50 atm but that’ll change quickly at this rate. Plus having a “trendy” lead means I can find co-op partners fairly easily.
Glad I came here first when I decided to look back into the game and how it was doing 😛
Huzzah and well done rerolling til Ed =)
It will be hard to dethrone him as a meta leader so you should be pretty set for a long time moving forward!
What do you think of the Fullmetal alchemist silver pocket watch ?
It is okay. The awakenings provided are nothing special and the actual active is lackluster
I tried to get Ed on my account with a pack of 30 stones and got all golds. Wouldn’t be doing that again! A day or two later, I pooled some of the march stones for a single roll and BAM! Ed.
Pretty stoked about having Edward on both accounts.
Well, I thought my monster box would enjoy some of the diversity the 6* could bring and as I had yet to be able to pull a solid Light leader I decided to dive in deep to this REM, hoping for an Edward.
Well, 20 rolls deep and I pulled only a single 6* – Bradley. R.I.P.
At least I have doubles of the golds for days?
That sounds like my Fantastic experience except I pulled 2 Bradleys….such a lackluster diamond =(